MMOGology: Addiction and you
Filed under: Real life, Culture, Opinion, MMOGology
A few months back I caught a report on NPR discussing whether video game addiction was an actual addiction. The guests on the show all agreed that it was a real phenomenon. There was even a former drug addict who called in and confessed that quitting his game was harder than quitting heroin. Although no specific game or games were mentioned, it was apparent that the caller was addicted to a massively multiplayer online game (MMOG).Since gaming is a maturing form of entertainment that has only recently merged into the mainstream it seems a popular target for non-gaming journalists seeking the next sensational story. It strikes a nerve with me when the press uses the word addiction in the context of video games because it carries a sinister connotation. It darkens an already gloomy perception of a hobby I love. Games have already been blamed for shootings and desensitization to violence. Now gamers have "addict" to add to our list of perceived sins. There seems to be an element of society eager to demonize gaming for whatever reason. Regardless of mainstream media misperception, video game addiction; especially MMOG addiction, is an oft recurring topic in the gaming community. So are MMOGs really addictive? If so, what elements make them addictive? If they are addictive, what should we do about it?
To start with, most non-physiological addictions require an element of pleasure. For a video game to be attractive and compelling it must be fun. Fun means different things to different people and great MMOGs cater to a variety of entertainment tastes. Some people love the competitive element of PvP. Others love creating their own objects in a virtual world via crafting. Whatever the form of entertainment, the game mechanics must be rewarding and enjoyable. They must feed our desire to "feel good now": to be rewarded frequently, to satiate our curiosity and desire to explore, and to generally do things that make us happy. To keep people entertained for long periods of time (to keep those subscriptions active), an MMOG must have enough content to keep players interested, and great MMOGs have content by the truckload. To experience all of this content, you must invest time into the game.
There is no denying that playing an MMOG is time consuming. Part of the reason why is because there is no real "end" to an MMOG. Most single player games have anywhere from 10 to 40 hours of playtime; usually leaning to the lower side of that range. MMOGs, on the other hand, last as long as you'd like to continue playing them. Even if you reach the highest attainable character level (if such a paradigm exists), it is often possible to continue with activities exclusively available for high level characters, or, to create alternate characters in addition to your main character. In fact, some would argue that the "real" game doesn't begin until you've maxed your character's level. So with most MMOGs there is a big time commitment. But that time commitment could be spread out over a long period of real-world time; unless there's a driving force to level up quickly. In most MMOGs, that's usually the case.
There is typically some degree of pressure that drives us to level up as quickly as we can. This pressure obviously doesn't exist in a vacuum; it exists because of the community of players with which we interact. Unlike single player video games, online games have an element of competition inherent in them due to their social nature. We desire to stay near the level of our friends so that we can continue playing together. We desire to obtain virtual property ("loot") that is better than our friends or rivals. We desire to best our rivals competitively in those MMOGs that support player versus player gameplay. We may even have a desire to win the heart of another player. All of these social pressures to excel and outperform one another are truly more associated with the community of players themselves, the virtual society, rather than the vehicle in which it manifests itself, the game. Game developers work to make their game as compelling as possible to keep the virtual society entertained, but one of the reasons that people devote a sometimes unhealthy amount of hours to MMOGs is due to the pressure players create themselves to succeed in "winning" the game; however winning is defined.
The heroin/gaming addict I mentioned earlier confessed to spending 10 to 12 hours a day playing his game. He said that it had a detrimental affect on his life because his daily functioning was impaired by his compulsion to participate in the game as often as he possibly could. His real-world romantic relationship suffered as well as his job. By all accounts, this man was truly addicted to a game because he had a recurring compulsion to engage in an activity that impaired his daily life. He was psychologically addicted to playing a video game.
So are MMOGs addictive? They are fun, they are time sinks, and there is peer pressure to succeed. MMOGs contain elements that, when working in unison can cause those with addictive personality types to be caught in an enjoyable, rewarding world that might be more fun than real life – and they might not want to leave as a result. So, yes, I believe MMOGs can be addictive. But before we demonize MMOGs and burn our copies of World of Warcraft let's step back momentarily and look at the larger picture of addiction. Life is chock full of addictive opportunities and almost anything pleasurable can be addictive. People have addictions to alcohol, food, gambling, sex, love, caffeine, and even work. Pick your poison; there are so many great choices. Rather than chastise video games, which, when played in moderation are a fun diversion, we should chastise ourselves for our lack of discipline.
There's a great children's book with a lesson on addiction, among other things. The book is a collection of short stories called Frog and Toad Together by Arnold Lobel. One of the stories is called "Cookies." Here is an excerpt:
Toad baked some cookies.
'These cookies smell very good,' said Toad.
He ate one.
'And they taste even better,' he said.
Toad ran to Frog's house.
'Frog, Frog,' cried Toad, 'taste these cookies that I have made.'
Frog ate one of the cookies.
'These are the best cookies I have ever eaten!' said Frog.
Frog and Toad ate many cookies, one after another.
You know, Toad,' said Frog, with his mouth full, 'I think we should stop eating. We will soon be sick.'
'You are right,' said Toad. 'Let us eat one last cookie, and then we will stop.'
'These cookies smell very good,' said Toad.
He ate one.
'And they taste even better,' he said.
Toad ran to Frog's house.
'Frog, Frog,' cried Toad, 'taste these cookies that I have made.'
Frog ate one of the cookies.
'These are the best cookies I have ever eaten!' said Frog.
Frog and Toad ate many cookies, one after another.
You know, Toad,' said Frog, with his mouth full, 'I think we should stop eating. We will soon be sick.'
'You are right,' said Toad. 'Let us eat one last cookie, and then we will stop.'
Shortly after this scene both Frog and Toad continue to eat cookies uncontrollably. Eventually however, they discover something called willpower and conquer their addiction.
Some addictions are psychological and some are physiological. Some addictions are more powerful than others. I don't mean to trivialize addiction or those who have suffered through addiction. However, if society continually caters to feeding our urge to "feel good now", regardless of what we do to feel good, than it seems we will continually be challenged to make good decisions on our own; to attempt to live life in moderation as best we can, and to exert a degree of willpower. Sure, we all fall down along the way. We're all n00bs at some point. That's OK as long as we pick ourselves up and learn from our mistakes.
Video gaming addiction is possible and is real, but, generally speaking, it is not as life threatening and scary as sensational media would like us to believe. Beating it seems to boil down to self-control, relaxing, and enjoying it as the hobby it is. Unless you're a professional gamer I guess; but then you're a work-a-holic.
The Empyrean Age is born in fire
Funcom announces names for early access servers
ION 08: John Smedley keynote shows off Free Realms and The Agency
Vivendi leaks a possible Wrath of the Lich King release date
SOE's The Agency and Free Realms will offer RMT services
MMOG Podcast Roundup: May 9th - May 16th
Massively goes to Seattle: A wrap-up of ION 2008
Player vs. Everything: Game-hopping like a madman
Ask Massively: Age of Conan survival guide (for your computer)
ION 08: Taking an MMO community from pre-launch to live
Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
11-05-2007 @ 10:53AM
Jinintaanik said...
Thank you for the Frog and Toad reference! I had that book when I was a kid, and remembering it made me smile!
I think that people with "addictive personalities" can become addicted to just about anything. I doesn't surprise me to hear about a former drug addict becoming addicted to something else. I don't think it has anything to do with the game, but rather the persons predisposition to addiction.
Reply
11-05-2007 @ 10:53AM
Adam R said...
Great article.
Call me a naysayer, but I put very little faith in the traditional media. I bet that news story, especially the heroin/MMO addict, was BS. Heroin is a drug that chemically alters your body and mind. No game can compare to that. I don't get a shot in the arm when I turn in Fel Armaments.
I'm sure the game can be addictive, don't get me wrong. But our modern news media needs to take a look at what MAKES these games so addictive before hyping up our parents, attempting to show a direct corrolation between, say, WoW and black tar heroin.
Getting to a high level and getting high are very different.
Reply
11-05-2007 @ 1:08PM
Girl Meets WoW said...
IMO, WoW Insider was more on the mark when they reported on it not being addiction, but enthrallment.
Reply
11-05-2007 @ 1:27PM
Speedmonkay said...
A while back when I first discovered MUDs, I was extremely addicted to them. It was a game where I could meet people from all over without having to leave my little room. They were massive games that always changed. I remember I wouldn't leave the room for anything but food and my room was off the kitchen so I wouldnt have to go far. My hygiene went to shit. Quite frequently I would stay up and game for 72 hours straight before just finally passing out wherever I was sitting and then get up again and get right back on again. I wouldnt leave the house for a job or anything. If I did leave the house and I got near a computer like at the library, I would find a way to telnet into the MUD to play more.
Now many years later I have a house and kid and professional job and all so I dont have time to get hooked on games (but that temptation to play LotRO at work is strong). But I do have a friend who is pretty badly addicted to FFXI like I was to MUDs.
I am a firm believer in game addiction. But unlike herion, which the body develops a physical dependancy to, I think games addiction is more of a psychological dependancy. I think the addiction really doesnt have much to do with the game. The game is just filling a hole in the person's life. When I got hooked on MUDs, I was at a extremely depressing point in my life. I needed another place to get away, other people to meet, something fun to do that I had never done before and the MUDs gave me that escape. Even now when I get down I find myself playing LotRO (or some other game I have) more than usual.
So I think they should treat people with game addiction similiar to other addictions - find out what is causing it and address that issue and not blame the game.
I'm just waiting to see someone who is severely addicted to a game be on a new episode of the TV show Intervention.
Reply
11-05-2007 @ 4:12PM
Snailking said...
The definition of addiction is repetitive behavior that continues despite damaging effects.
I am a former drug addict. Relapsed once.
I am a continuing MMO addict. Relapsed 10+ times.
My game addiction has damaged my life *way* more than drugs ever did.
I could talk about this subject very, very extensively, but this is not where/how to do it, obviously.
Reply
11-05-2007 @ 4:34PM
marc.nottke said...
Hi everyone,
Just wanted to say thanks for taking the time to read this article and I really, really appreciate your insightful, candid responses to this issue.
Marc
Reply
11-06-2007 @ 2:28AM
Bigfoot said...
This is a great read.
I started getting into MMOs years ago when I was in middle school. I can definitely say they are addictive. Many times I never wanted to go out and play with my friends or leave the house. I'd stay up to ridiculous hours compared to what I was used to, just so I could play a little bit longer.
I'll have to question your statement at the end of your article though. You said "it is not as life threatening and scary as sensational media would like us to believe." Haven't there been a few cases where players have died due to 3 days of non-stop playing? I think one died in an internet cafe in China or something. I can't remember exactly.
Reply
11-07-2007 @ 11:50AM
Sensadiva said...
I believe video games are inherently "addictive". Video games are designed and marketed so consumers will purchase and play them. How you ask? By making them enjoyable.
Anything enjoyable is "addictive", that is harnessing the potential to yield addiction. I appreciate when you pointed out that "[p]eople have addictions to alcohol, food, gambling, sex, love, caffeine, and even work". I could extend this list to include exercising, 12 step programs, television, writing, pornography, religion, education, etc. These abstractions seem to be not the cause of our "addictions" but the focus of them.
For me, the underlying question that your post presents is:
Why do we demonize indulgence? Do our puritanical roots imbue us to downplay our passions? What would the world be like if we embraced such perceived indifference?
I am fortunate enough to have passion at one time or another for most of the things on your list:
http://sensadiva.blogspot.com/2007/09/wine-snobs-to-beer-slobs-wild-saturday.html
An old school poet, Alfred Lord Tennyson may have said it best:
"The happiness of a man in this life does not consist in the absence but in the mastery of his passions".
In another light, indulgence is not the root of evil but the cornerstone of accomplishment.
Reply
1-09-2008 @ 2:57PM
tb said...
Like most gamers, your response to MMO addiction takes a defensive stance. You are quick to defend your hobby, but the funny thing is that no one is attacking it.
The media gave us a story about someone who had a problem with addiction to an MMO. The story is a warning to people with addictive personalities or depression.
If you choose to interpret it as an attack on your hobby, perhaps you should re-evaluate your own feelings about said hobby. In other words, if you are satisfied with your relationship to MMOs, then why get so defensive about it?
The point stands. Addiction is the problem, not the games. But your average person on the street has no idea that these games have the potential to be addictive, the way we all know alcohol can be, for instance.
Until that is common knowledge, expect more media stories like this one to educate people.
Reply