Behind the Curtain: Don't be ashamed
Filed under: World of Warcraft, Culture, Behind the Curtain, Politics
Picture the scene – you're at a family gathering, or maybe you're meeting your significant other's friends and family for the first time, and the conversation turns interrogative. Questions are asked about your hobbies; what you do to relax and how you spend your spare time. What do you do? When put on the spot like that, it's natural for gamers to feel trapped, to feel like admitting to playing MMOs would be tantamount to admitting to a rather kinky fetish or confessing that you've got a rather embarrassing disease – it might not be catching, but there's a chance that you'll get some funny looks, and you may just lose some credibility points.
What about job interviews and applications? These invariably have a point where questions are asked about you hobbies and leisure time. While there are good arguments that putting down strong examples of guild leadership might work in your favour – owning up to the fact that you play an MMO upwards of 15 hours a week might not be the smartest thing career-wise.
Don't get me wrong – I am proud and happy to be a geek and a gamer, and I've never wanted to be anything else; the wall above my desk sports a rare Akira poster I picked up on holiday France a while back; I own the complete boxed set of the original Transformers series; and much of my wardrobe consists of t-shirts from ThinkGeek and the Penny Arcade store. People ask me what I do in my spare time, and I look them straight in the eye and tell them that I'm a gamer, and while I'm not ashamed of it, I can't help but wince a little when I see most people's reaction to it.
I guess one of the problems here lies with people like Jack Thompson, Leland Yee and Keith Vaz, people who appear to have convinced media outlets like Fox News and the Daily Mail that computer games in general are little more than 'murder simulators' – a claim that millions of healthy, well-balanced gamers around the world can attest to being ridiculous.
For every example and argument that people like this put forward about how bad games are and how they do nothing but corrupt young people and destroy the foundations of society by ruining our ability to communicate and associate with 'real people', there are arguments and examples we can present to counter them; times you've shared jokes with people from the other side of the world; times when a complete stranger helped you for no reason other than the kindness of their heart; times where a few choice words from you raised the spirits of your friends just enough to make the final successful attempt at a boss they thought you'd never beat; times where you found yourself stepping up to the plate to organise 20 or 40 people to come together as a cohesive team for the first time; times where you stay up far too late not because you're addicted and can't leave the keyboard, but because you've just made 4 new friends, and you're simply having too much fun to feel tired.
With all this, we are still looked down on by so many people. Images of sweaty, overweight nerds nurturing their snow-white tans in front of a brightly-shining monitor, whacking giant rats and pretending to be Elves, immediately spring to mind when you mention to people that you're an MMO gamer. You might have to explain to them exactly what an MMO game is, but as soon as they grasp the concept, you can see the images forming in their mind.
Think about how many times you've had to defend your time spent online. I don't mean trying to justify it to your parents when you're supposed to be studying – I'm too scared to argue with my own mother, let alone yours – I mean defending it to people who have just found out what you do with your spare time, people who barely know you or the games you play – people who form their opinions based on what they've been told instead of what they've found out for themselves.
I think that part of the solution to this lies in education. If we could only educate our parents, our loved ones, and the doubters and hysterics who refuse to see gaming as anything but a child's pastime and a sad refusal to deal with reality, then I think we would see a change. Unfortunately, saying that and accomplishing it are two rather different things.
How does one go about changing the attitudes of society? By demonstrating, campaigning, and educating? Are our guild leaders supposed to hand out homework to us now, instructing us to bring a friend or relative to the next raid, to show them what really happens when we're sitting at the computer for hours on end? Will we be taking to the streets to show our solidarity the next time an ambulance chaser blames an atrocity on computer games?
Fat chance, what if you've got a raid scheduled that night? We'll make do with flaming the critics on our guild's forum. One of the reasons that gamers have a bad reputation is that we're an easy target – we don't have a collective voice, an individual or even a collection of individuals who speak on our behalf. If you're taking nominations, I can think of a few names that would get my vote.
Hell, even hackers have a manifesto, but what do we have? To accomplish a change in people's perception of gamers, we need to come together as a community and present a united face to the people who would spread lies and misinformation about our chosen pastime.
I wonder – how long until playing computer games, and MMO games in particular, won't be looked down on by the world at large? The people who dropped coin after coin into Space Invaders and Pacman machines years ago have grown up and given birth to a generation of gamers for whom MMO games are going to be a staple of their gaming diet – but does that mean that we're going to have to wait another 10 years before they grow up and their attitudes towards MMOs start to dictate how they're viewed?
We, as gamers, are legion, and it's about time the rest of the world caught up with us, and stopped trying to make us embarrassed and ashamed about doing something we love.

















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
Quinnae said on 10:45PM 5-22-2008
I have to say I loved this piece. I might read it to my parents when I see them next. *winks*
I think at the end of the day we, as a bunch, are a bit too diverse to speak with one voice. I've actually promoted that message on some forums but ultimately got flamed. :P Which is typical in an oddly endearing way. Our playstyles vary almost infinitely. There are all sorts of gamers out there- there are plenty of hardcore gamers that totally eschew MMOs as a sick art- as this site showed recently, actually.
There are PvPers, Roleplayers, raiders, dungeon runners, soloists and mixtures of all the above. Hardcores, softcores, Molten Cores, casuals, and all the rest. Politically speaking, diverse groups *can* speak with one voice, naturally, but when it comes to speaking for a past time like gaming, some people may not think it worth the effort. A big chunk of people who play wouldn't want to be seen as taking it that seriously, as that might play into the hands of our enemies.
I feel that this generation will grow into the halls of power, just as the children of the Baby Boom and the start of the Cold War who were always threatened with having their comic books banned became the politicians of today. It won't be terribly long before we have presidents, prime ministers, chancellors, ministers, MPs, and senators who played WoW. Even as we speak, American congressmen are making bad jokes about WoW in a non threatening manner- so there's hope!
Like any new artistic medium, it will take time to be accepted. Back when they were new, even novels were excoriated as trash and unworthy of polite society. Now they're what today's highbrow say we should have our nose in as opposed to these games.
Time: A level 500 raid boss. None can defeat it. *winks*
Reply
Nadril said on 5:58PM 5-26-2008
I agree that it is going to take time for the medium to be accepted. As Quinnae said all mediums go through a stage where they are considered filth, and we just happen to be in that stage where video games is part of it.
I think that in 15 or 20 years time we'll see a lot more gamers in the media and in powerful positions -- and then I think we'll start to see gaming become a more recognized medium.
Either way the only other hurdle I've heard people talk about is the idea that games are not artistic as movies or books. Of course, as a gamer, I have to disagree. While it was true that 15 years ago games didn't have much to go on (although you could consider games such as pac man, donkey kong and other old-school games artistic) to 'wow' critics. Now with technology as it is game developers are able to express what they want much easier.
The best thing that some developers have taken advantage of is the fact that you can experience the story first hand. Instead of just being a bystander you have an effect, a voice so to speak, in what is going on. When more developers use this idea to its full extent (showing less cutscenes when they can) then it will be much more efficient.
For example, GTA 4. While it does have cutscenes to show some parts almost all of the major turning points in the storyline have you acting it out. Any of the executions YOU act out, and I think it helps much more than if you were just to watch it happen.
Reply
suvana said on 8:10AM 5-23-2008
Why don't you write a Gamer's Manifesto? :)
Reply
Craig Withers said on 9:25AM 5-23-2008
Quinnae - you're right in that that kind of behaviour is endearing in a certain way, but it's also endearing to watch your baby nephew bounce of walls while he's learning to walk, but it does stop being funny eventually. Part of me loves that, as a community, we are ridiculously diverse and fragmented, but another part of me hates it because it's the same thing that's preventing us from coming together.
Nadril - the 'games as art' debate is one that I'm loathe to tackle. I agree that it will take time before games become more widely accepted, but I think it's going to take an awfule lot longer than it did for any other form of entertainment, due simply to the very nature of the medium.
suvana - Honestly, I don't think I'm the right person to even attempt that - if I did, I think you'd be able to see the flames from orbit :D
Reply