Go back to school with your Mac, iPhone and TUAW

World of WarcraftWorld of Warcraft
Linden Lab's big content takedown

Filed under: Economy, News items, Second Life, Legal, Virtual worlds

There are widespread reports today that Linden Lab has removed all content from Second Life (from in-world, and from user inventories and object contents) that were the work of a small number of users, apparently over DMCA issues.

Hitherto, Linden Lab has a reputation for only taking down specific, identified items in-world -- stuff that you could point to. Indeed, it attracted criticism for not also removing other copies of such items from in-world and from user-inventories.

Now, it seems the Lab is going large, and doing just that.

Two of the names mentioned so far are Eva Capalini, and Loni Arado -- neither of whom appear in the Second Life user database anymore (banned or canceled accounts).

The content in question appear to be scripts and textures which have been either distributed as free, full-permissions items, or sold for incorporation in other products -- and therein lies the problem.

Hincapie Schmertzin (posting on the Second Life forums) said, "We are running a shoe business and based many of our shoes on patterns bought from Loni Arado. Every pattern was obviously purchased in good faith - just as our buyers bought shoes in good faith. Today, we and they woke up to every single pair of shoes being non-rezzable. As such, the problem has ended up in the hands of ordinary secondlifers running businesses."

Second Life user Joshua Nightshade has created a JIRA issue, requesting clarification from Linden Lab for their apparently unannounced change in DMCA policy.

The affected content appears to be scripts and textures, many of which are widely used. It seems that any content with Eva Capalini or Loni Arado listed as the creator is simply no longer available, including sculpt-textures and widely used animation/pose scripts.

Reports are a little confused as to whether objects containing the blacklisted components were removed entirely, or whether only the components themselves are no longer available within the system, but in the cases we've verified so far, it seems to be the latter. This seems to particularly affect many versions of the very popular 'MLP scripts' (originally created by Miffy Fluffy) and widely used in a large variety of products over a number of years.

To be clear, Miffy Fluffy's content is still good, but certain copies of it by some other creators may not be. Various textures from other creators are similarly affected.

If you purchased such a product, the content is now broken, and you've wound up the loser. The creators who have had their content blacklisted have more than likely profited from the venture. The store where you bought your lost products may have acquired the components in good faith.

Certainly, the move could well shake the faith in the Second Life economy, as many quite reputable creators and sellers are affected by this, and the loss of confidence may injure the businesses of many more. Additionally, we have what appears to be a change in action policy without prior notice.

Wholesale content removal (based on a correct or incorrect claim) is the norm in many DMCA actions online. The remover of the content (in this case) Linden Lab, is indemnified by the DMCA for any liability or loss to third parties as a result of such a content takedown, so long as the procedure is followed rigorously.

It's conceivable that some creators will start to put up signs to reassure customers, about refund policies or claiming 100% original content -- but people who are stealing content are able to do the same, so that's hardly a good guide.

It is rumored that Linden Lab will be making some sort of official statement on the matter in the coming days.

We have contacted Linden Lab for official comment.

[Follow-up here]

Related Headlines

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 2)

Add your comments

Please keep your comments relevant to this blog entry. Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments.

When you enter your name and email address, you'll be sent a link to confirm your comment, and a password. To leave another comment, just use that password.

To create a live link, simply type the URL (including http://) or email address and we will make it a live link for you. You can put up to 3 URLs in your comments. Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted — no need to use <p> or <br /> tags.

Massively Features

Featured Galleries


follow massively at http://twitter.com
    News
    Academic rss feed
    At a glance rss feed
    Betas rss feed
    Bugs rss feed
    Business models rss feed
    Classes rss feed
    Contests rss feed
    Crafting rss feed
    Culture rss feed
    Economy rss feed
    Education rss feed
    Endgame rss feed
    Events, in-game rss feed
    Events, real-world rss feed
    Expansions rss feed
    Exploits rss feed
    Forums rss feed
    Game mechanics rss feed
    Guilds rss feed
    Hands-on rss feed
    Humor rss feed
    Interviews rss feed
    Launches rss feed
    Legal rss feed
    Lore rss feed
    Machinima rss feed
    Maps rss feed
    Massively highlights rss feed
    Massively meta rss feed
    MMO industry rss feed
    New titles rss feed
    News items rss feed
    Opinion rss feed
    Patches rss feed
    Player Housing rss feed
    Politics rss feed
    Previews rss feed
    Professions rss feed
    PvE rss feed
    PvP rss feed
    Races rss feed
    Reviews rss feed
    Roleplaying rss feed
    Rumors rss feed
    Server downtime rss feed
    Trading card games rss feed
    Virtual worlds rss feed
    Features
    Anti-Aliased rss feed
    Ask Massively rss feed
    Behind the Curtain rss feed
    EVE Evolved rss feed
    Making/Money rss feed
    Massively Event Coverage rss feed
    Massively Hands-on rss feed
    Massively Interviews rss feed
    Massively Speaking rss feed
    MMO MMOnkey rss feed
    MMOGology rss feed
    One Shots rss feed
    Player Consequences rss feed
    The Daily Grind rss feed
    The Digital Continuum rss feed
    TurpsterVision rss feed
    Strategy
    Grouping rss feed
    Guides rss feed
    Leveling rss feed
    Making money rss feed
    Quests rss feed
    Raiding rss feed
    Tips and tricks rss feed
    Media
    Comics rss feed
    Fan art rss feed
    Galleries rss feed
    Podcasts rss feed
    Polls rss feed
    Screenshots rss feed
    Trailers rss feed
    Video rss feed
    Wallpapers rss feed
    Genres
    Browser rss feed
    Casual rss feed
    Consoles rss feed
    Crime rss feed
    Fantasy rss feed
    Free-to-play rss feed
    Historical rss feed
    Horror rss feed
    Kids rss feed
    Linux rss feed
    Mac rss feed
    MMOFPS rss feed
    MMORTS rss feed
    Mobile rss feed
    MUDs rss feed
    Puzzle rss feed
    Real life rss feed
    Sci-fi rss feed
    Sports rss feed
    Spy rss feed
    Super-hero rss feed
    War rss feed
    MMOs
    2Moons rss feed
    9Dragons rss feed
    Age of Conan rss feed
    Aion rss feed
    Albatross 18