Don't miss Joystiq's up-to-the-minute live coverage of E3!

World of WarcraftWorld of Warcraft
Player Consequences: The Need for Speed

Filed under: World of Warcraft, Age of Conan, EVE Online, Jumpgate Evolution, Game mechanics, Opinion, Blackstar, Player Consequences

Traveling has always been one of the least popular parts of playing a MMO. It doesn't matter if you are marching through the lengthy Connall's Valley in Age of Conan or travelling across the galaxy in EVE Online. It can be tedious no matter what the setting. Nice visuals and guild chat can occupy you part of the time, but you still check the map every other minute. We're lucky that MMO design has come a long way since the early days, where the only option was to hit the road on foot. Most games now give us vehicles, mounts, and in some cases mechanical ostriches to speed up the pace a bit. After all, if it's the journey and not the destination that matters then you definitely want to travel in style.

There is one underlying reason why travel times continue to be prevalent in MMOs today and it's directly related to player expectations of virtual worlds. Developers are very sensitive to the issue of making their games seem like a real world and not a collection of three dimensional video game levels. Any MMO that has too many instances and separate zones often gets complaints for breaking the feel of a seamless world. This can actually turn players away from the game. As a result, the most successful games are often those with an over-world where players don't find themselves constantly having to load data as they zone. Just look at how World of Warcraft, Lord of the Rings Online, and EVE Online handle their world design.

Developers can take this overboard though and make worlds that are a little too massive in size sometimes. Games that don't properly fill in their world with quests and mobs have a boring and monotonous feeling to them. However, even when a massive world has been properly filled with content, it can still be a pain to travel through. Players often have to meet up with their friends in specific locations and travel time can become a limiting factor against forming a group. Mounts have become a common solution in MMOs that allow players to decrease their travel time without reducing the size of the actual world.

This isn't the only reason why we continue to see mounts being included in most MMO designs. Some wise guy working for Blizzard quickly figured out that mounts make a good status symbol and World of Warcraft soon had a wide variety of them. Players just cannot get enough of mounts offered through those limited time special events and holidays. This demand for a unique mount continues to exist even after the events are over. This has made them into the perfect money sink for games. The more unique and fast the mount, the more money it can remove from the economy.

Mounts aren't just a simple travel mechanism anymore. A lot of games have integrated them more directly into their game play. Age of Conan has introduced mounts with different abilities, which become useful in different types of combat situations. Giant war mammoths are slow and almost useless for fighting a person, but they do great damage against city walls. Horses on the other hand allow for quickly running down any opponents who happen to be on foot. The mounted combat in Age of Conan still has some kinks that need to be worked out, but other games have also integrated mounts and vehicles into their combat.

EVE Online uses no avatars at all and its players experience the game only through the cockpit of different space ships. You could say one is always "mounted" when playing EVE Online. This doesn't seem to detract anything from the combat since the game often receives praise for having exciting and strategy filled battles. It's not for everyone though, since a majority of MMO players are used to being directly involved in combat though an avatar. In fact, EVE Online is the only successful game I can think of where players spend a majority of their time in a vehicle.

Auto Assault and Pirates of the Burning Sea are the other two widely known vehicle based games, and they both have a checkered past. Auto Assault did not include any sort of avatar interactions and had problems capturing enough subscribers to keep itself afloat. Pirates of the Burning Sea on the other hand rushed out poorly designed avatar combat at the last minute. Many reviewers criticized this decision and claimed it was only included to increase market appeal. This might be the case since the history of vehicle based MMOs in the Western market is pretty bleak. Eastern games have had more success with hits like Exteel and Kart Rider becoming popular.

The Western market does not seem to have the same fascination with vehicle based combat unless the MMO involves space ships for some reason. As a result, the majority of MMOs are following what the market seems to want and staying away from games that are strictly based on mount or vehicle based combat. That's not to say mounts and vehicles are going to remain just for traveling. Mounted combat seems to be in demand and even more exciting is that several games are experimenting with aerial combat. Footage from some of the Wrath of the Lich King previews highlighted players fighting while mounted on Wyverns and Gyrocopters. Other games are sure to follow in the footsteps of World of Warcraft if this catches on.

More evolutionary than Blizzard's aerial combat are the different space based MMOs currently under development. Jumpgate Evolution is primarily a vehicle based game like EVE Online, but seems to be following a more casual friendly philosophy. On the other end of the spectrum, we have Blackstar, which uses an impressive mixture of avatar and vehicle based combat. Both games are setting an example by using vehicles heavily throughout their game play. What this means for the future of mounted combat in MMOs is hard to say. Chances are strong though that we're seeing a trend of moving away from treating mounts and vehicles as simple modes of transportation. While they still fulfill our need for speed, they also have many more applications in MMO design.


Gabriel Runfeldt Gabriel Runfeldt has been following MMOs ever since he stumbled onto an EverQuest addiction by accident. He eventually managed to fight it off but caught a case of armchair designer syndrome in the process. Now once a week you can catch his mad ravings here at Player Consequences. You can even contact him with any questions at gabriel.runfeldt AT weblogsinc.com

Related Headlines

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)

Add your comments

Please keep your comments relevant to this blog entry. Email addresses are never displayed, but they are required to confirm your comments.

When you enter your name and email address, you'll be sent a link to confirm your comment, and a password. To leave another comment, just use that password.

To create a live link, simply type the URL (including http://) or email address and we will make it a live link for you. You can put up to 3 URLs in your comments. Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted — no need to use <p> or <br /> tags.

Massively Features

Featured Galleries


follow massively at http://twitter.com
    News
    Academic rss feed
    At a glance rss feed
    Betas rss feed
    Bugs rss feed
    Business models rss feed
    Classes rss feed
    Contests rss feed
    Crafting rss feed
    Culture rss feed
    Economy rss feed
    Education rss feed
    Endgame rss feed
    Events, in-game rss feed
    Events, real-world rss feed
    Expansions rss feed
    Exploits rss feed
    Forums rss feed
    Game mechanics rss feed
    Guilds rss feed
    Hands-on rss feed
    Humor rss feed
    Interviews rss feed
    Launches rss feed
    Legal rss feed
    Lore rss feed
    Machinima rss feed
    Maps rss feed
    Massively highlights rss feed
    Massively meta rss feed
    MMO industry rss feed
    New titles rss feed
    News items rss feed
    Opinion rss feed
    Patches rss feed
    Player Housing rss feed
    Politics rss feed
    Previews rss feed
    Professions rss feed
    PvE rss feed
    PvP rss feed
    Races rss feed
    Reviews rss feed
    Roleplaying rss feed
    Rumors rss feed
    Server downtime rss feed
    Trading card games rss feed
    Virtual worlds rss feed
    Features
    Anti-Aliased rss feed
    Ask Massively rss feed
    Behind the Curtain rss feed
    EVE Evolved rss feed
    Making/Money rss feed
    Massively Event Coverage rss feed
    Massively Hands-on rss feed
    Massively Interviews rss feed
    Massively Speaking rss feed
    MMO MMOnkey rss feed
    MMOGology rss feed
    One Shots rss feed
    Player Consequences rss feed
    The Daily Grind rss feed
    The Digital Continuum rss feed
    TurpsterVision rss feed
    Strategy
    Grouping rss feed
    Guides rss feed
    Leveling rss feed
    Making money rss feed
    Quests rss feed
    Raiding rss feed
    Tips and tricks rss feed
    Media
    Comics rss feed
    Fan art rss feed
    Galleries rss feed
    Podcasts rss feed
    Polls rss feed
    Screenshots rss feed
    Trailers rss feed
    Video rss feed
    Wallpapers rss feed
    Genres
    Browser rss feed
    Casual rss feed
    Consoles rss feed
    Crime rss feed
    Fantasy rss feed
    Free-to-play rss feed
    Historical rss feed
    Horror rss feed
    Kids rss feed
    Linux rss feed
    Mac rss feed
    MMOFPS rss feed
    MMORTS rss feed
    Mobile rss feed
    MUDs rss feed
    Puzzle rss feed
    Real life rss feed
    Sci-fi rss feed
    Sports rss feed
    Spy rss feed
    Super-hero rss feed
    War rss feed
    MMOs
    2Moons rss feed
    9Dragons rss feed
    Age of Conan rss feed
    Aion rss feed
    Albatross 18 rss feed
    All Points Bulletin rss feed
    Anarchy Online rss feed
    Animal Crossing rss feed
    ArchLord rss feed
    Arden rss feed
    Asheron's Call rss feed
    Barbie Girls rss feed
    Battlefield Heroes rss feed
    Black Prophecy rss feed
    Blackstar rss feed
    Blue Mars rss feed
    Bounty Bay Online rss feed
    Cabal Online rss feed
    Champions Online rss feed
    Chronicles of Spellborn rss feed
    City of Heroes rss feed
    City of Villains rss feed
    Club Penguin rss feed
    Concerto Gate rss feed
    Corum Online rss feed
    CrimeCraft rss feed
    Dark Age of Camelot rss feed
    DarkEden Online rss feed
    Darkfall rss feed
    DC Universe Online rss feed
    Dekaron rss feed
    Dofus rss feed
    Dream of Mirror Online rss feed
    Dreamlords rss feed
    Dungeon Runners rss feed
    Dungeons and Dragons Online rss feed
    Earth Eternal rss feed
    Earthrise rss feed
    Empire of Sports rss feed
    Entropia Universe rss feed
    Eternal Lands rss feed
    Eudemons Online rss feed
    EVE Online rss feed
    EverQuest rss feed
    EverQuest II rss feed
    Everquest Online Adventures rss feed
    Exanimus rss feed
    Exteel rss feed
    Face of Mankind rss feed
    Fallen Earth rss feed
    Fiesta rss feed
    Final Fantasy XI rss feed
    Flyff rss feed
    Football Manager Live rss feed
    Freaky Creatures rss feed
    Free Realms rss feed
    Fury rss feed
    FusionFall rss feed
    Gaia Online rss feed
    Global Agenda rss feed
    Gods and Heroes rss feed
    Godswar Online rss feed
    Grand Chase rss feed
    Guild Wars rss feed
    Guild Wars 2 rss feed
    Habbo Hotel rss feed
    Hellgate: London rss feed
    Hello Kitty Online rss feed
    Hero Online rss feed
    HiPiHi rss feed
    Holic rss feed
    Home rss feed
    Horizons rss feed
    Huxley rss feed
    Infinity rss feed
    Irth Worlds rss feed
    Jumpgate rss feed
    Jumpgate Evolution rss feed
    Kingdom of Loathing rss feed
    Kingdom Under Fire rss feed
    Knight Online rss feed
    Last Chaos rss feed
    Legend of Mir: The Three Heroes rss feed
    Legends of Norrath rss feed
    LEGO Universe rss feed
    Lineage rss feed
    Lineage 2 rss feed
    Lively rss feed
    Lord of the Rings Online rss feed
    Love rss feed
    Mabinogi rss feed
    MagiKnights rss feed
    MapleStory rss feed
    Marvel Universe Online rss feed
    Mechscape rss feed
    Meridian 59 rss feed
    MetaPlace rss feed
    Might and Magic rss feed
    Minions of Mirth rss feed
    Mortal Online rss feed
    Moshi Monsters rss feed
    MU Online rss feed
    Myst Online: URU Live rss feed
    Myth War Online rss feed
    Mythos rss feed
    Neocron 2 rss feed
    Nexus: The Kingdoms of the Winds rss feed
    Oberin rss feed
    Perfect World rss feed
    Phantasy Star Universe rss feed
    Pirates of the Burning Sea rss feed
    Pirates of the Caribbean Online rss feed
    PlaneShift rss feed
    PlanetSide