Western MMO fan plays Eastern MMO, gets disoriented
Filed under: Fantasy, Culture, Humor, Mabinogi
There's an article over at The Escapist that tells the story of a hardcore Western-style MMO player who tries out an Eastern-style MMO and experiences a bit of culture shock. The article is written by WarCry Senior Editor John Funk.The game he tries to play is Mabinogi (of which we've published our own first impressions), and he dedicates himself to playing it for one week. During that week, he plays it for a total of 30 hours. That means he played the same game four and a half hours a day for seven days straight. We're not sure there are many games Western, Eastern, or otherwise that can stand up in that kind of intensity but he weathers through it! Comedy occurs as he struggles to understand random owl visits and perplexing user-interface functionality.
At first it seems like the article is asking if the game mechanics of an Eastern MMO are destined to be completely lost in translation for Western players, but in the end Funk cops out into another direction. Still, it's humorous and occasionally almost insightful, so check it out if the topic interests you.















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)
8-31-2008 @ 9:44AM
recursive said...
I don't feel he's copping out. The Eastern-Western thing is so cliche. Sure there's a grain of truth to it, but we're not really talking about the same games, even if they're the third-person and bash-the-mob type on the outside. Can you honestly compare Mabinogi and WoW? I daresay a similar experience could happen to someone switching to EVE or deciding to give SL a go.
Of course, this is a problem developers trying to do something new have to overcome and which can be quite.. tough. If we must make it about East-West, we're probably more spoiled and less accepting of that kind of thing over here, but I think mr Funk for one did well not just writing the game off because of it.
Reply
8-31-2008 @ 11:47AM
Hardy said...
I've played probably 20 or more eastern MMOs just to try them out. I meant their free, I kind of like the Micro transaction service more then a monthly fee.
Though many of them did suck, there were a couple that stood out. Sword of the New World, Fly For Fun, Ryzom to name a few. I saw the potential in them.
I say the biggest difference, like what this article says at the end, from western and eastern MMOs is that westerns cater to solo play, while eastern ones mainly say "%^&* you solo, find some friends!"
We've been but in a weird mindset for MMOs because of games like where, where an MMO can be just.. MO.
I won't deny the effort some of these developers take making eastern MMOs.
I still prefer western MMOs though. lol they have more money to do stuff, which is unfortunate because I'm sure if some eastern MMOs had a lot of money, they'd blow WoW out of the water.
Reply
8-31-2008 @ 4:33PM
Rollins said...
Not to nitpick, but Ryzom's a western MMO.