GoonSwarm alliance disbanded in EVE Online political drama
Filed under: Sci-fi, EVE Online, Culture, Interviews, Lore, PvP, Endgame, Hands-on, Politics
In the sandbox of New Eden, rival alliances vie for control of vast swathes of star systems. The lawless nullsec regions of the EVE Online universe are home to violent alliances of all sizes and fleets with hundreds of ships clash on a daily basis. The political machinations of nullsec have produced many stories of wars fought over territory, stations conquered and fleets dismantled by force. Over the years, each story has become part of the game's living history. Recently, a new chapter in that history began as the nullsec sovereignty system governing territorial warfare received a complete overhaul in the Dominion expansion. The transition period has been rough on some alliances as a new sovereignty system requires new ways of thinking. Some alliances are falling, new ones are being forged to fill the power vacuum and the race is on for people to adapt to the new sovereignty system.
As we've been watching the EVE galaxy performing its Darwinian reshuffle, it came to our surprise that GoonSwarm, the game's biggest territorial alliance, had been disbanded. In the early hours of Wednesday 3rd February 2010, GoonSwarm CEO "karttoon" kicked almost every corp from the alliance, effectively disbanding it. There's more to this story than meets the eye and in this investigative piece, I delve into the thick of it to discover just what's going on with this troubled alliance.
Who are GoonSwarm?:
GoonSwarm is an alliance forged from an out-of-game community. The members, called "goons", are almost all from the Something Awful forum and the main corp GoonFleet was set up as a way for forum members to play EVE with each other. They quickly became a dominant force in nullsec territorial warfare and are famed for their suicide-ganking antics as JihadSwarm.
Goonswarm is perhaps best known for their all-out war against the Band of Brothers alliance as part of a coalition of territorial alliances. This time last year, they succeeded in destroying Band of Brothers using dubious but acceptable spying tactics. When a new recruit turned out to be a character owned by a current Band of Brothers director, Goonswarm spymaster "The Mittani" lept on the chance to deal the alliance a crippling blow from the inside. On 4th February 2009, the Band of Brothers alliance was disbanded by their new director-level spy. As if to rub salt in the wound, the goons then registered a new corporation with the name "Band of Brothers" to prevent the name being reclaimed.
When the story broke of Goonswarm's disbandment, rumours began to circulate on whether or not the act was malicious. Did the alliance plan all of this as part of a restructuring effort or had they fallen victim to the same vile crime they had perpertrated exactly one year ago? The fact that most corps were unaware of their impending dismissal and that the alliance wallets were emptied lends credibility to the theory that this was a malicious attack. In the moments following the ejection of corps from the alliance, standings issues even caused a SuperCarrier to be ejected from the force field of its staging starbase in 31-MLU. The pilot managed to evade the enemy for some time but the ship was eventually found and destroyed.
Massively caught up with Ex-CEO and previous CSM representative Darius JOHNSON to get his take on the whole situation.
Massively: Do you consider the alliance effectively hijacked or had this been planned for a while?
Darius: Firstly I don't believe for a second it was "planned for a while". The organizational structure of Goonfleet is such that the CEO wields supreme power. Therefore the CEO has the capability to choose to or not to disband at any time. Kartton was a terrible CEO. He made some bad decisions. Goons called him on those decisions and he chose to be a giant baby and "punish" them by disbanding the alliance.
Darius: Really there was a loss of assets, but the space had already been lost due to his lack of management ability. So the assets and corp name were in essence just water under the bridge that goons couldn't access because he was an absentee. A withdrawal [from Delve] began the day the bills were not paid and the sov dropped, allowing IT to take major stations within 10 hours of the change in status.
Massively: Any idea what they're doing with the whole BoB name thing?
Darius: The BoB name was originally claimed by me when we shut them down. When I retired I entrusted it to Karttoon, who I imagine will keep it.
Massively: Is the old Goonfleet corp still functional at all? Do you think that karttoon might be still planning to run the alliance?
Darius: Goonfleet the corp will not be functional at all. Karttoon has full control and will simply squat it. He has no intention of establishing any form of alliance whatsoever. Firstly he lacks the chops. He was handed a giant and quite complete package.
Massively: What direction are you planning to take with GoonWaffe?
Darius: Waffe has returned to the Goon's ancestral home in Syndicate. The Goonfleet members are taking their time switching over to the new corporation. There's the matter of roles which adds 24 hours to the process, so we won't see a huge boost until today. Goonwaffe will serve much the same role as Goonfleet did albeit with better leadership and a somewhat altered mission.
Massively: Do you expect to lose members due to this event?
Darius: I don't expect [we] will lose anyone to this. We've always been united by a common external community [...]. A simple alliance dissolution in game cannot come between us [...].
What went wrong?:
Evidently, the story of GoonSwarm's disbanding goes back to the appointment of karttoon as CEO. Because of their dictatorial political structure, the CEO was in a position of complete authority within the alliance. He was the only person allowed access to the corp wallet and so the only person capable of paying upkeep bills on system sovereignty. Last week on 26th January 2010, upkeep for GoonSwarm's sovereignty-keeping structures lapsed and the alliance lost their defensive infrastructure. With cynosural jammers and jump bridges down, enemies "IT Alliance" and "Against All Authorities" began to overrun Delve. This comes with the added sting that Delve was the former home of Band of Brothers and that several key corps from Band of Brothers are now in the attacking IT Alliance, fighting to reclaim their lost home.
In a post on the Something Awful forums, karttoon stated that the upkeep had accidentally lapsed while he was on a long holiday. He suggested that he had previously planned to destroy the alliance and simply took this opportunity to carry out his plan. After emptying the alliance wallet and taking billions of ISK in ship reserves from his corp's strategic ship depot, karttoon proceeded to boot every major corp from the alliance. As a final act of defiance, he moved the primary goon corp "GoonFleet" into the "Band of Brothers" holding alliance they had set up after dismantling BoB last year. Having suspected that karttoon might do something like this, Darius had ensured that the secondary goon corp "GoonWaffe" was kept under his command. He now urges goons to reunite under the GoonWaffe banner and return to their roots in Syndicate region.
Final thoughts:
The words "GoonSwarm is dead" are a cause to rejoice for many pilots but the reality is much less dramatic. As the alliance is based around a community outside the game, perhaps "GoonSwarm" was essentially just a name. Time will tell how many ex-goons will reform into GoonWaffe and what their new place in EVE's political landscape will be but at this stage, the goons appear to be far from dead. Strange things are afoot in EVE Online, but aren't they always?
As we've been watching the EVE galaxy performing its Darwinian reshuffle, it came to our surprise that GoonSwarm, the game's biggest territorial alliance, had been disbanded. In the early hours of Wednesday 3rd February 2010, GoonSwarm CEO "karttoon" kicked almost every corp from the alliance, effectively disbanding it. There's more to this story than meets the eye and in this investigative piece, I delve into the thick of it to discover just what's going on with this troubled alliance.
Who are GoonSwarm?:

GoonSwarm is an alliance forged from an out-of-game community. The members, called "goons", are almost all from the Something Awful forum and the main corp GoonFleet was set up as a way for forum members to play EVE with each other. They quickly became a dominant force in nullsec territorial warfare and are famed for their suicide-ganking antics as JihadSwarm.
Goonswarm is perhaps best known for their all-out war against the Band of Brothers alliance as part of a coalition of territorial alliances. This time last year, they succeeded in destroying Band of Brothers using dubious but acceptable spying tactics. When a new recruit turned out to be a character owned by a current Band of Brothers director, Goonswarm spymaster "The Mittani" lept on the chance to deal the alliance a crippling blow from the inside. On 4th February 2009, the Band of Brothers alliance was disbanded by their new director-level spy. As if to rub salt in the wound, the goons then registered a new corporation with the name "Band of Brothers" to prevent the name being reclaimed.
When the story broke of Goonswarm's disbandment, rumours began to circulate on whether or not the act was malicious. Did the alliance plan all of this as part of a restructuring effort or had they fallen victim to the same vile crime they had perpertrated exactly one year ago? The fact that most corps were unaware of their impending dismissal and that the alliance wallets were emptied lends credibility to the theory that this was a malicious attack. In the moments following the ejection of corps from the alliance, standings issues even caused a SuperCarrier to be ejected from the force field of its staging starbase in 31-MLU. The pilot managed to evade the enemy for some time but the ship was eventually found and destroyed.
Massively caught up with Ex-CEO and previous CSM representative Darius JOHNSON to get his take on the whole situation.
Massively: Do you consider the alliance effectively hijacked or had this been planned for a while?
Darius: Firstly I don't believe for a second it was "planned for a while". The organizational structure of Goonfleet is such that the CEO wields supreme power. Therefore the CEO has the capability to choose to or not to disband at any time. Kartton was a terrible CEO. He made some bad decisions. Goons called him on those decisions and he chose to be a giant baby and "punish" them by disbanding the alliance.
Darius: Really there was a loss of assets, but the space had already been lost due to his lack of management ability. So the assets and corp name were in essence just water under the bridge that goons couldn't access because he was an absentee. A withdrawal [from Delve] began the day the bills were not paid and the sov dropped, allowing IT to take major stations within 10 hours of the change in status.
Massively: Any idea what they're doing with the whole BoB name thing?
Darius: The BoB name was originally claimed by me when we shut them down. When I retired I entrusted it to Karttoon, who I imagine will keep it.
Massively: Is the old Goonfleet corp still functional at all? Do you think that karttoon might be still planning to run the alliance?
Darius: Goonfleet the corp will not be functional at all. Karttoon has full control and will simply squat it. He has no intention of establishing any form of alliance whatsoever. Firstly he lacks the chops. He was handed a giant and quite complete package.
Massively: What direction are you planning to take with GoonWaffe?
Darius: Waffe has returned to the Goon's ancestral home in Syndicate. The Goonfleet members are taking their time switching over to the new corporation. There's the matter of roles which adds 24 hours to the process, so we won't see a huge boost until today. Goonwaffe will serve much the same role as Goonfleet did albeit with better leadership and a somewhat altered mission.
Massively: Do you expect to lose members due to this event?
Darius: I don't expect [we] will lose anyone to this. We've always been united by a common external community [...]. A simple alliance dissolution in game cannot come between us [...].
What went wrong?:

Evidently, the story of GoonSwarm's disbanding goes back to the appointment of karttoon as CEO. Because of their dictatorial political structure, the CEO was in a position of complete authority within the alliance. He was the only person allowed access to the corp wallet and so the only person capable of paying upkeep bills on system sovereignty. Last week on 26th January 2010, upkeep for GoonSwarm's sovereignty-keeping structures lapsed and the alliance lost their defensive infrastructure. With cynosural jammers and jump bridges down, enemies "IT Alliance" and "Against All Authorities" began to overrun Delve. This comes with the added sting that Delve was the former home of Band of Brothers and that several key corps from Band of Brothers are now in the attacking IT Alliance, fighting to reclaim their lost home.
In a post on the Something Awful forums, karttoon stated that the upkeep had accidentally lapsed while he was on a long holiday. He suggested that he had previously planned to destroy the alliance and simply took this opportunity to carry out his plan. After emptying the alliance wallet and taking billions of ISK in ship reserves from his corp's strategic ship depot, karttoon proceeded to boot every major corp from the alliance. As a final act of defiance, he moved the primary goon corp "GoonFleet" into the "Band of Brothers" holding alliance they had set up after dismantling BoB last year. Having suspected that karttoon might do something like this, Darius had ensured that the secondary goon corp "GoonWaffe" was kept under his command. He now urges goons to reunite under the GoonWaffe banner and return to their roots in Syndicate region.
Final thoughts:
The words "GoonSwarm is dead" are a cause to rejoice for many pilots but the reality is much less dramatic. As the alliance is based around a community outside the game, perhaps "GoonSwarm" was essentially just a name. Time will tell how many ex-goons will reform into GoonWaffe and what their new place in EVE's political landscape will be but at this stage, the goons appear to be far from dead. Strange things are afoot in EVE Online, but aren't they always?
















Reader Comments (Page 1 of 3)
DrewIW said on 8:17PM 2-04-2010
I have to agree with Darius that this was not a premeditated act. karttoon was always impulsive and emotional in his decisions, and after being called on to resign, I think his attitude was simply "if I can't have it, no one can".
I think after setting up shop in Syndicate, we can expect to see Goonwaffe sending fleets north to fight Tri and company.
Goons in Syndicate. BoB(IT) in Delve. The circle is complete.
Reply
Yoh said on 8:30PM 2-04-2010
Huh? I didn't see that one coming.
Sure, I knew Goonswarm were getting torn to shreds due to the new sov changes, but I didn't expect this level of drama.
But that's EVE for you.
~Yoh
Reply
Ves said on 8:48PM 2-04-2010
Only in EVE, you have to love this game.
Reply
Brian! said on 12:29AM 2-05-2010
+1 Love the idea of Eve, can't keep playing it for more than a few weeks.
My last run I was doing ok. But when it comes down to it, it is too high level of ship management for me. I want an EvE game where I am sitting in the cockpit and my actual real skill of flying will be the thing that makes or breaks my future. Not the price and loadout of my ship.
I always dreamed of a game where large ships exist, but they take guilds to fly. Like guns can auto fire, but it is no replacement for having someone in a gunner seat actually shooting.
Dalrint said on 8:51PM 2-04-2010
Am I the only person who doesn't like playing Eve, but absolutely loves reading about the eve politics stuff?
It actually got me to try the game, in fact. Couldn't hold my attention at all. But MAN, the drama is awesome...
Reply
vanity-name said on 9:10PM 2-04-2010
I'm exactly the same. I tried EVE, it's just not a good fit for me. I like open-ended stuff, but my MO is Machiavelli-style conflict avoidance (why fight if you don't have to?), you really have to have the mindset of a conflict-seeker to get into the metagaming in EVE. That said, I love all these crazy stories, including The Mittani's column "Sins of a Solar Spymaster".
Din A3 said on 9:56PM 2-04-2010
Yeah, me too. I loved the metagame, but the actual game bores me to tears. Already tried it three times.
breezer said on 11:09AM 2-05-2010
was going to say exactly the same thing. If only click n watching myself warp for hours a day were a fraction as interesting as reading about EVE drama....
InfamousBrad said on 9:53AM 2-05-2010
No, it's not even vaguely just you. Auto-fly auto-shoot combat bores me, combat at such long ranges I can't even see the enemy ships bores me, spending 35 hours mining or farming pirates to be able to afford 5 hours of PvP bores me; the actual game is so boring that I can't imagine how anybody but the most completely obsessive compulsive player stands it. But CCP the company, as the most aggressive anti-cheating anti-gold-selling MMO company out there, fascinates me (HTFU indeed). And for all that it sounds on some level like junior high school clique versus clique stuff, they dress it up so pretty that faction warfare stories are fun to read.
Zen said on 5:24AM 2-06-2010
I love reading this stuff, too. I haven't even played the game (can't dedicate that much time) but I do enjoy their movies, screenshots and stories.
This kind of emergent (meta)gaming is simply terrific, and I applaud CCP for excelling at keeping the players engaged.
Andrew said on 3:01PM 2-06-2010
Yup. Love the drama, hate the game mechanics.
Dblade said on 9:03PM 2-04-2010
The ceo went on vacation, forgot to pay the bills, and caused loss of territory. Then he either ragedisbanded the alliance, or chose to anyways. It sounds a lot more interesting than it really is. If anything the Providence/-A- fighting is probably a better story and more meaningful.
Reply
Dblade said on 9:05PM 2-04-2010
edit: the CVA versus -A- I mean. The games biggest Not Red-Don't Shoot alliance for some reason makes a power grab for a system and is getting hammered. Actual fighting and drama ensue.
James said on 1:06PM 2-05-2010
I just left LFA.... I'm a little surprised how organized these large alliances are, yet when they go to war they are extremely unorganized and don't plan anything. At least that's what it seemed like in Providence. Why CVA and LFA teamed up to try and claim territory without a good strategy seems strange to me. Napoleon had the same problem :P
Load of Idiots said on 9:06PM 2-04-2010
I dont play in EvE myself but I always find the stories and the drama that come out of the game far better than anything developers have ever created for us in theme parks. If more games allowed room to create these sorts of structures while still offering the theme park option....I imagine it'd be quite entertaining but I dont think anything can ever match the level of EvE.
Hopefully we'll hear some new interesting story of the GoonWaffe going after some sweet justice on their defacto Goonswarm leader..then again ... one can never really predict what those guys will do. No doubt they're already planning some interesting tactics for STO's pvp areas.
Reply
UnSub said on 9:06PM 2-04-2010
There's no drama like EvE drama.
Reply
Cinnamoon said on 9:06PM 2-04-2010
I don't even understand why Massively covers this sort of thing. Guilds and alliances are a dime a dozen in every game; megalithic communities explode on a daily basis everywhere. I don't care for the drama garbage in games I AM playing let alone others, and it's certainly not newsworthy when Some Dude decides to screw over his mates.
Reply
Siphaed said on 9:32PM 2-04-2010
Because EVE is a sandbox game where you (the player) makes their own fun and things of this sort are perfectly legal within the game. Did you know that Guild Bank theft in World of Warcraft is against the ToS and is bannable? Ya, you can get banned in WoW if you take someone's 'precious' objects. In EVE Online, it's a legitimate way to play the game and topple other corporations from the inside out.
I guess the thing about it is that the game is more open and free and it's the way players have essentially formed the game for themselves. Lowsec right now is mostly owned by a handful of large alliances, but when the game came out it was all free for all and control of it was scattered between hundreds of corporations. The game evolved as the player base wielded it to.
It's alot more interesting to hear "Big corporation alliance X toppled corporation alliance Y and now controls all of their 8 sectors and stations" than to hear something like "Big boss X was first killed by guild Y" when eventually it will be killed hundreds of thousands of times more by players (essentially a STATIC FIGHT). The corporation/alliance battles of EVE are far more dynamic, some are 'once-in-a-lifetime' events that'll never come again.
GaaaaaH said on 9:49PM 2-04-2010
This is a major alliance ingame and the effects could be widely felt
ninjapony said on 10:26PM 2-04-2010
Just think of it this way. Prior to a couple days ago, all of Stranglethorn Vale, Elwyn Forest, and Goldshire were owned by one guild. These 3 zones are also all free-for-all pvp flagged, including the major towns, including Stormwind. Then, the guild controlling a massive chunk of some of the most popular territory in-game screwed up their guild settings, were betrayed by their guildmaster, and were set upon by thousands of other players they'd managed to piss off so many times in so many ways there hasn't been a word invented yet to describe it.
Then, imagine that ingame assets can only be accessed from the bank you originally deposited them in, and that you can be ganked and have all your assets yoinked off your cold, dead corpse.
Finally, imagine that all this happened on one gigantic shard, and that this shard is the only shard, and thus affects every single player of the game, and not just one small subset playing on one of hundreds of shards.
All of this is why EVE gets this type of coverage. WoW.com blogs about when a guild gets a world-first PVE endgame kill. This type of activity is EVE's endgame, thus it gets reported on by Massively, mainly because Weblogs Inc/AOL/whoever doesn't run a dedicated EVE blog(but they should :D.)